4 responses to “Recommended Reading for June 1, 2010”

  1. sexgenderbody

    Thanks for the link! I love this site and you folks have been on our blogroll for months.

    -arvan

  2. Willow

    A 2008 study, but Mind Hacks posted a link to it today so I thought y’all might be interested nevertheless:

    Disease Rankings

    ranking the “prestige” of a decently sizable list of illnesses, disorders and injuries. Heart attacks and leukemia are apparently the most prestigious. Mental illnesses are, as you might expect, grouped at the bottom, with anorexia and schizophrenia squeaking in just under AIDS, and fibromyalgia last. The abstract of the original study notes that this might have some effect on what specialties prospective doctors choose, which patients get treated–and, I would think, what gets research money and probably also a factor in how patients are treated?

    (Sorry if this has been posted here before!)

  3. jeneli

    I’m a bit confused by the study because I have no idea how they’re defining prestige. And who on earth thinks of prestige when they think of medical conditions anyway? Is prestige supposed to be some combination of the severity/potential life-threatening nature of a disease? Or it is supposed to imply that doctors who specialise in certain things are more flashy than others?

    I don’t get it!

  4. Ruchama

    I’m not sure exactly what “prestige” means, either, but I’m guessing it means something like that doctors who treat certain diseases are considered more important? Anyway, looking at that list, it seems like the ones at the top of the list are generally potentially fatal, and the usual treatment for them is either surgery or something intensive like chemotherapy or radiation. The ones toward the bottom of the list are more likely chronic diseases that affect quality of life but generally aren’t fatal, and the few that are fatal are the ones that are incurable — the ones at the top of the list are things like cancer, where someone can be declared cured after being cancer-free for a certain period of time, or things like appendicitis that require emergency surgery and then the patient is better, and the doctor is a hero. The bottom of the list has a lot of things like arthritis and AIDS and MS, where the doctor might be able to prescribe drugs or therapy that make the patient feel better or live somewhat longer, but the doctors don’t have that same “I cured him/her” ending that they’d get with the others.

Subscribe without commenting